Nearly five years into his pontificate, Pope Francis still has not visited his homeland
The papal flight to Chile lasted about 15 hours and flew over the Pope Francis’ native Argentina, where many in the church, politics and chattering classes wondered aloud: When will he arrive here?
After Argentine Cardinal Jose Mario Bergoglio was elected Pope in March 2013, many Argentines expected he would put his home country on the top of his list of countries to visit. Nearly five years later, Pope Francis has travelled four times to Latin America, but not Argentina.
As he flew over Argentine airspace January 15, he sent a brief message to Argentine President Mauricio Macri, blessing the people and reminding them: “Do not forget to pray for me.”
The Pope has never announced any firm plans to visit, though church observers voice opinions that he would prefer to avoid the polarisation of Argentine politics, especially because, as archbishop of Buenos Aires, he often criticised corruption and ministered to the marginalised.
Politicians on all sides have tried to claim the Pope as one of their own — a fellow traveller, who would embrace their cause if he were in the country. Some old friends are sometimes seen as informal spokesmen for the Pope.
“These so-called ‘friends of the Pope’ do not help because they’re part of the ‘grieta'” — or crack, as Argentines call their political polarisation – “and media, interestingly, present them as spokesmen of the Holy Father,” said Tito Garabal, a Catholic journalist in Buenos Aires, who has known Pope Francis for more than 20 years.
“They’re repeating falsehoods that many people believe are true, and then it has to be said that the Pope never said such things,” he added.
The Argentine bishops’ conference issued a statement, asking people to stop talking on behalf the Pope, to not use him for political purposes and to avoid “tendentious and partial interpretations” of his speeches, which have “only widened the divisions between Argentines.”
“This constant association” — of the Pope with others in Argentina — “has generated confusion and justified regrettable distortions of his figure and his words,” the statement said.
“The immense majority of Argentines love Pope Francis. They do not confuse him with those who try to use him, pretend to represent him or attribute imaginary positions according to their own sectoral interests. Common people want to hear the Holy Father’s teachings and recognise it by his clear and plain language,” the statement continued.
Pope Francis visits Chile and Peru from January 15–21, his fourth trip to South America. Observers are split on whether he will ever visit Argentina.
“I have the impression that the Argentine bishops don’t know what to say,” said Jose Maria Poirier, editor of the Catholic magazine Criterio in Buenos Aires.
“On one hand, they want to show total unity with the Pope, but, on the other, many of them don’t understand,” Poirier said, adding that perceptions of the Pope intervening in domestic politics “causes discomfort”.
Garabal said the Pope had other more urgent issues than returning to Argentina for a homecoming.
“There are more urgent matters in the world than those in Argentina, which are created by our own history of division,” said Garabal, who visited Pope Francis in 2016. “I know the Holy Father wishes to come here, but there isn’t much time, and the world and ecclesiastical emergencies are many.”